US | MLB Justices Don't Buy MLB's Fantasy Pitch Using players' real names in for-profit leagues is free speech, Supreme Court rules By Nick McMaster Posted Jun 2, 2008 2:15 PM CDT Copied Fantasy leagues argued that, under free-speech law, the names and statistics of baseball players like New York's Derek Jeter could be used without paying a fee, the Los Angeles Times reports. (AP Photo/Rob Carr) The Supreme Court refused today to hear an appeal by Major League Baseball against a ruling that allowed fantasy sports leagues to use real players' names and stats without paying a licensing fee, the Los Angeles Times reports. MLB contended such leagues shouldn't "exploit players' identity for commercial gain;" the for-profit ventures said free-speech law allows it. Read These Next Kyrsten Sinema is being sued under 'homewrecker' law. Norwegians are flabbergasted by Machado's Nobel giveaway. Pamela Anderson didn't love sitting near Seth Rogen at the Globes. John Mellencamp's little-known side gig: Indiana football fan. Report an error